blog.indahnesia.com - Discover Indonesia Online

    
You are currently in > Just a blog about Indonesia > Scientists query discovery of 'Hobbits' in Flores


Scientists query discovery of 'Hobbits' in Flores JAKARTA - A row has broken out about the scientific evidence purporting to show that a species of "hobbits" lived on a remote Indonesian island about 18,000 years ago. A team of scientists believes that the skull at the centre of the discovery is not from a metre-high member of another human species but belonged to someone with microcephaly - a congenitally small brained person.

Allegations have been made before but this time the doubters over the hobbit - formally called Homo floresiensis - accuse other scientists of poor science and the media of hype. The latest criticism has emerged in the American journal Science, whereas the original study was published in the British journal Nature. It is not the first time that the two publications have apparently tried to rubbish each other's articles.

When the study about a new species of dwarfed human being was published in Nature in 2004 it was heralded as one of the most important discoveries in anthropology for a century. The partial skeleton of a female was found on the island of Flores. She stood about 3 feet tall with a small head perfectly in proportion to her body, containing a brain the size of a grapefruit.

But Science soon published doubts about the find after scientists suspected that the skeleton belonged to a prehistoric member of our own species who suffered from microcephaly. If the claims are true, it would mean that the find did not warrant the accolade of a new human species, and certainly not one with the miniaturised features of the so-called hobbit.

But following the American journal's claims, a study by Dean Falk, of Florida State University, also published in Science, appeared to cast doubt on the microcephaly revisionists. Professor Falk compared brains scans of Homo floresiensis with the skull of a modern microcephalic and concluded that the two had few similarities. However, a third study in Science criticises Professor Falk's study as scientifically flawed because the scientists used a single, defective brain cast made more than 100 years ago of a 10-year-old microcephalic boy.

Professor Robert Martin, of the Field Museum in Chicago, who led the study, said that the brain capacity of the skull found on Flores is not big enough to be capable of making the sophisticated stone tools found at the cave site on Flores. Professor Martin also criticised Professor Falk for using a poor-quality cast of the braincase of a microcephalic boy with a severe version of the condition, rather than comparing the "hobbit" to an adult with a milder form of the condition.

"This defective plaster copy of a microcephalic skull used in the study... is inappropriate, especially one with a topic as demanding and high-profile as this one," Professor Martin said. "Quite simply, it was the worst possible choice for this study. The cranial capacity turned out to be only 260 cubic centimetres, just over half of that recorded for the [Flores ] skull, and is one of the smallest I have so far found in a survey of more than 100 human microcephalics," he said.

He added that the only plausible explanation for the small size of the skull found on Flores is that it belonged to a microcephalic person who lived into adulthood. "There has been too much media hype and too little critical scientific evaluation surrounding this discovery, and it is unacceptable that papers should be published without providing proper details of the specimens examined," Professor Martin said. "The principle of replicability is fundamental to good science, and it has not been respected in this case."


Related blog entries (category 'General') Related blog entries (category 'General'):
11 October 2005 · Scientists in Indonesia find evidence of another 'Hobbit'
07 November 2004 · Hobbit folk 'were just sick humans'
28 October 2004 · Little lady of Flores forces rethink of human evolution


Posted in General @ 19 May 2006 07:05 CET by Jeroen · 'Blog' RSS feed · permalink






There are no reactions on this blog entry yet. Be the first one to give a reaction here!


Log in to write a reaction

You are not logged in to the website. You have to be logged in to write a reaction on this blog entry.

· If you already have an account, please login.
· If you have lost your password, please retrieve it.
· If you don't have an account yet, you can create one.

    
 ABOUT THIS ENTRY
Add this blog entry to your email, your own blog, MySpace, Facebook, or whatsoever via AddThis:
Bookmark and Share

e-mail updates for this blog article

Login if you want to receive emails for reactions on this blog entry. You will receive an update as soon as a reaction on this blog entry is posted.

Your website for tickets in Indonesia!
Looking for e-tickets for flights in Indonesia? Here's your solution! Order your e-tickets at ticketindonesia.info.
 FOLLOW US ON TWITTER
 BLOG ARCHIVE
· 2015, 28 entries
· 2014, 591 entries
· 2013, 750 entries
· 2012, 1061 entries
· 2011, 792 entries
· 2010, 644 entries
· 2009, 916 entries
· 2008, 504 entries
· 2007, 725 entries
· 2006, 1014 entries
· 2005, 723 entries
· 2004, 558 entries
· 2003, 525 entries
· 2002, 375 entries
· 2001, 162 entries
 POPULAR TAGS
· gigolo
· jakarta
· blogger
Automatically generated every hour
 BLOG CATEGORIES
· General (1205 entries)
· Economy (643 entries)
· Politics (574 entries)
· Accidents (561 entries)
· Terrorism (541 entries)
· Earthquake (539 entries)
· Volcanoes (387 entries)
· Crime (357 entries)
· Corruption (349 entries)
· Flooding (278 entries)
· Elections (276 entries)
· Travel (268 entries)
· Bird Flu (254 entries)
· Religion (242 entries)
· Tourism (239 entries)
· Oddly enough ... (219 entries)
· Violence (198 entries)
· Drugs (196 entries)
· Health (192 entries)
· Aceh conflict (191 entries)
· Environment (185 entries)
· Weather (171 entries)
· Military (168 entries)
· Protests (157 entries)
· Culture (106 entries)
· Garuda Indonesia (91 entries)
· C. Sulawesi conflict (86 entries)
· Human rights (82 entries)
· Forest fires (78 entries)
· Sidoarjo mudflow (71 entries)
· Power supply (64 entries)
· Ramadan (63 entries)
· PT Freeport (55 entries)
· Picture guess (48 entries)
· Maluku conflict (47 entries)
· History (37 entries)
· Dengue Fever (37 entries)
· Infrastructure (36 entries)
· Polio (35 entries)
· Mexican flu (35 entries)
· Website (25 entries)
· Media (22 entries)
· Nuclear power (21 entries)
· Sports (20 entries)
· Sexy (16 entries)
· SARS (15 entries)
· Nightlife (10 entries)
· Others (5 entries)
· Lippo Cikarang (5 entries)
· Close smallest categories
 EXCHANGE RATES
EUR-IDR: 16,590 · 16,620  The Rupiah rate declined since yesterday
@ 17 May 2018 18:12 CET
JPY-IDR: 126.83 · 126.95  The Rupiah rate improved since yesterday
@ 17 May 2018 21:58 CET
MYR-IDR: 3,545 · 3,549  The Rupiah rate declined since yesterday
@ 15 May 2018 08:42 CET
SGD-IDR: 10,479 · 10,501  The Rupiah rate declined since yesterday
@ 07 May 2018 07:48 CET
THB-IDR: 439.14 · 439.41  The Rupiah rate declined since yesterday
@ 16 May 2018 09:18 CET
USD-IDR: 14,097 · 14,157  The Rupiah rate declined since yesterday
@ 17 May 2018 00:46 CET
Go to 'exchange rates' 
 MOST RECENT REACTIONS
·  At 20 September 2018 06:54 erik12 reacted on Fuel prices lowered, again
·  At 19 October 2015 17:17 imambudianto5 reacted on Bank Indonesia maintains benchmark interest rate at 7.75%
·  At 04 March 2015 19:18 merdekaSah reacted on Alleged terrorists shot dead three villagers in Poso
·  At 04 March 2015 13:11 Yogya-Bali reacted on Alleged terrorists shot dead three villagers in Poso
·  At 26 February 2015 13:02 Irena reacted on Sexy, a young woman with candy
·  At 08 May 2014 09:51 jstar reacted on No alcohol should be sold in warung
·  At 01 May 2014 10:07 jstar reacted on Indonesia to be among the top 10 peacekeeping contributors
·  At 27 March 2014 05:50 harlys reacted on PPP leader voices concern over Islamic parties' future
·  At 10 March 2014 06:11 Yogya-Bali reacted on Sriwijaya Air leaves behind 200 passengers at airport
·  At 09 March 2014 00:11 Yerun reacted on Sriwijaya Air leaves behind 200 passengers at airport
·  At 08 March 2014 20:33 nicknick reacted on Sriwijaya Air leaves behind 200 passengers at airport
·  At 18 February 2014 04:17 Yerun reacted on Ash from Mount Kelud eruption spreads over all of Java
·  At 16 February 2014 05:41 Amed East Bali reacted on Ash from Mount Kelud eruption spreads over all of Java
·  At 14 February 2014 22:27 Anne Mieke reacted on Asylum seekers in Medan wish to be sent to Australia
·  At 14 February 2014 22:22 beritaislam reacted on Asylum seekers in Medan wish to be sent to Australia
·  At 16 January 2014 15:37 Anne Mieke reacted on Landslides cut off Tomohon-Manado road
·  At 16 January 2014 15:21 Yerun reacted on Landslides cut off Tomohon-Manado road
·  At 16 January 2014 15:05 Anne Mieke reacted on Landslides cut off Tomohon-Manado road
·  At 16 January 2014 14:48 Yerun reacted on Landslides cut off Tomohon-Manado road
·  At 16 January 2014 14:41 Yerun reacted on Landslides cut off Tomohon-Manado road
Go to 'forum topics' 

Created by indahnesia.com · feedback & contact · © 2000-2019
Other websites by indahnesia.com: ticketindonesia.info · kamus-online.com · indonesiepagina.nl · suvono.nl

Valid HTML 4.01 Transitional 122,167,982 pageviews Discover Indonesia Online at indahnesia.com